Discussion
Topic: One Day
Has anyone loved a book so much that they just CAN’T watch the movie adaptation? I absolutely refuse to watch the movie version of One Day because I don’t want to taint the book experience.
9 comments
Benjamin Lemley Not exactly the same thing but I thought the giver movie was just really bad and I never want to watch it again
2 Likes
Julie Zantopoulos Totally counts. It’s tough when you love a story and the adaptation isn’t what you want it to be.
1 Likes
Ella The 5th Wave… the book was amazing. It was the first time I’d ever read the book first and the movie came out as soon as I finished it. I was so excited… and so let down… they changed everything
1 Likes
Julie Zantopoulos That’s a book/movie I haven’t read but it’s why I’m hesitating to watch the Grisha show. I don’t want the books/characters ruined.
Like
DJ The Three Musketeers. I just cannot watch a movie that I think will ruin that book for me.
1 Likes
Julie Zantopoulos Pretty sure I’ve only seen the Disney cartoon version lol
1 Likes
Joslyn I can’t really figure out if Normal People is supposed to be a tear jerker, coming of age, or romance, but I absolutely hated the book and series lol I think in the opposite sense, I was hoping the series would have made me appreciate the book more 😂
2 Likes
Julie Zantopoulos Sometimes it does that. Like a bad book will translate better to film. I think Daisy Jones and the Six by Taylor Jenkins Reid will do much better as a movie but I HATED the book format.
1 Likes
Heather I too loved the series and totally disliked the book🤷🏼♀️
Like
Zoe The Outsiders. everyone either says the movie was really good or really bad. but i don’t want to watch it bc i thought the book was so well written. i’ve always wanted to write a book like that and it is a great example for what i wanna do. so i feel like if i watch the movie, that’s just gonna take away the magic i had while reading the book. i just wouldn’t be the same. my role model book would change and i wouldn’t really like that.
1 Likes
Julie Zantopoulos I loved the book and haven’t seen the movie. Hmmm maybe that’s another that I can add to my list
Like
Teeba DIY Ahah me too! I just feel like it would ruin the book
1 Likes
Alexis I stay away from most shows that are based off of books I love. I keep having to ask people, “did you read the book first” and then “does it hold up?” before I will even give it a chance. Same with movies.
1 Likes
Shelly Haskell I just binged the Netflix mini series. I 😍 it! So excited that it’s a book🥰. I get to enjoy this again. I don’t usually go to a book if I’ve seen movie but I know the book will take me away. #oneday #moviebeforebook #reallove
Like
Heather I’m kinda the opposite with the Harry Potter series. I never read the books before seeing the movies, which I adore, so now I am afraid to read the books for fear of not finding the movies as enchanting. Anyone else?
Like